top of page

Goodman v. Kennedy: When Does an Attorney Owe a Duty to the Other Side?

Writer: kestner  Law
kestner Law
Oct 31
4 min read

When a buyer loses money in a business transaction, can the seller's attorney be held responsible for giving negligent legal advice to the seller? In Goodman v. Kennedy, the California Supreme Court said generally no—unless the attorney's advice was meant to reach and be relied on by the buyer, or the facts created a separate duty to disclose information.

What happened

The plaintiffs bought stock from officers of a corporation. The sellers' attorney had advised his clients about issuing and selling the stock without losing an exemption from federal registration requirements. After the exemption was suspended, the stock lost value and the buyers sued the attorney for negligence, fraud, and securities-law violations.

The trial court dismissed the case at the pleading stage. The California Supreme Court affirmed that dismissal because the complaint did not allege facts establishing that the attorney owed the buyers a duty of care or a duty to disclose the omitted information.

An attorney's duty usually follows the attorney-client relationship

An attorney normally owes professional duties to the client who hired the attorney. That duty does not automatically extend to every third party who may be affected by the client's transaction.

The Court explained that a duty to a nonclient may exist when the attorney's legal advice was foreseeably transmitted to and relied on by that person, or when the person was an intended beneficiary of the transaction. But the buyers in Goodman were simply people negotiating an arm's-length stock purchase. They were not the intended beneficiaries of the attorney's work for the sellers.

Why the Court protected the attorney-client relationship

The Court was concerned that expanding negligence liability to opposing parties would change how attorneys advise their own clients. If an attorney could be sued by anyone dealing with the client, the attorney might become overly cautious and focus on avoiding claims from outsiders instead of giving the client complete and effective advice.

In the Court's view, that would burden the legal profession and reduce the quality of legal services. The attorney's role is to counsel the client—not to act as a neutral adviser for the other side in an arm's-length negotiation.

Why will-drafting cases are different

The buyers relied on cases involving attorneys who negligently drafted wills. In those cases, an intended beneficiary may sue because the attorney's work was specifically intended to transfer property to that beneficiary. The beneficiary's benefit was the central purpose of the legal work.

Goodman was different. The buyers were not intended beneficiaries. Any benefit they might have received from buying the stock was only a side effect of a private business bargain. That collateral advantage did not create an attorney-client-like relationship or a professional duty to the buyers.

Negligence is different from fraud

The Court made an important distinction: the limits on an attorney's negligence liability to third parties do not protect an attorney from liability for actual fraud. An attorney cannot avoid responsibility for intentionally deceptive conduct simply by saying the attorney was acting for a client.

But a fraud claim based only on silence still requires a legal duty to speak. Silence is not automatically fraud. The plaintiff must first show why the defendant was required to disclose the information.

When does a duty to disclose exist?

The Court identified several situations that may create a duty to disclose:

  • A confidential or trust-based relationship exists between the parties.

  • The defendant made a statement that would be misleading without additional information.

  • The defendant actively concealed an important fact.

  • The defendant alone knew or had access to a material fact, knew the other party did not know it, and knew the fact could not reasonably be discovered by that party.

The Goodman plaintiffs did not allege enough specific facts to fit any of these categories. They also did not adequately show that they reasonably relied on the attorney's silence or that the attorney knew the omitted facts were material and unavailable to them.

Why the securities-law claim failed

California's Corporate Securities Law prohibits using a false or misleading statement to induce someone to buy stock, including omitting information needed to keep a statement from being misleading. But the complaint did not identify an untrue statement by the attorney or a statement that became misleading because of something left unsaid.

The Court therefore concluded that the securities-law claim also failed. Merely having a conversation about a proposed stock sale was not enough to establish a misleading communication.

The practical lesson

Goodman v. Kennedy does not give attorneys permission to lie or hide material facts when they have a duty to disclose. Instead, it draws a boundary around ordinary legal advice given to a client in an arm's-length transaction.

For a nonclient to bring a successful claim, the facts must show more than foreseeable harm. The plaintiff generally must show a relationship, intended reliance, intended benefit, misleading conduct, active concealment, or exclusive access to important information that could not reasonably be discovered elsewhere.

Key takeaway

An attorney representing one side of a business deal usually does not owe the other side a negligence duty merely because the other side may be affected by the advice. But fraud and nondisclosure claims can still proceed when specific facts establish a duty to speak and reasonable reliance on what was said—or left unsaid.

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page