top of page

When the Rules Change: What Happens When Banks and Borrowers Try to Rewrite Home Loans?

Writer: kestner  Law
kestner Law
Nov 1
4 min read

When people take out a loan to buy a house, they sign two major documents: a promissory note (a written promise to pay back the money) and a deed of trust (which acts like a mortgage, giving the lender the right to take the house if the borrower fails to pay).


Sometimes, life happens, and homeowners fall behind on their payments. To avoid losing their homes, borrowers often try to work out a deal with the bank. But what happens when the bank and the homeowner agree to change the rules of the loan—or when a dispute arises over whether those new rules are even legal?


Two California court cases, Secrest v. Security National Mortgage Loan Trust and Taniguchi v. Restoration Homes, look at how the law handles these kinds of loan changes and who has the upper hand.


Case 1: Secrest – Can a Bank Make a Promise Over the Phone Without Signing Anything?

In the Secrest case from 2008, a couple named Luther and Charmella Secrest fell behind on their home loan. They spoke with a bank representative over the phone who offered them a new deal: if they wired a down payment of about $13,422, the bank would stop foreclosure efforts, audit the loan history, and send a corrected, official agreement.


The Secrests paid the money and signed the paperwork the bank faxed over. However, the bank never did the audit, never sent a final signed copy, and eventually sold the loan to a new company. That new company tried to foreclose on the home. The Secrests sued, arguing that the phone agreement stopped the foreclosure.


The Court’s Decision:

The court ruled in favor of the bank. Why? Because of a legal rule called the Statute of Frauds.


  • What is the Statute of Frauds? It is an old legal rule requiring certain important contracts—like the sale or modification of real estate agreements—to be put into writing and signed by the party being held to it (in this case, the bank).


Because the bank never officially signed the new paperwork, the phone agreement wasn't legally binding. The Secrests argued that paying the money should count as "part performance" (meaning they held up their end of the bargain), but the court disagreed, ruling that simply paying money isn't enough to bypass the requirement for a signed contract.


Case 2: Taniguchi – What Happens When a Modified Loan Goes Wrong?

Fast forward to 2019 with the Taniguchi case. Charles and Marie Louise Taniguchi fell behind on their mortgage and agreed to a loan modification (a permanent change to the terms of the loan, such as lowering monthly payments and rolling unpaid interest and fees into a new, larger balance).


The modification agreement had a "catch": it stated that if the Taniguchis defaulted again, the lender could cancel the modification entirely and force them to pay off the original loan terms—which included tens of thousands of dollars in old, deferred debt that had been pushed to the end of the loan.


When the Taniguchis missed a few modified payments later on, the lender tried to foreclose and demanded they pay off all the old historical debt immediately to save their home. The Taniguchis sued, pointing to Civil Code section 2924c, a California law giving homeowners the right to reinstate (catch up on) a defaulted loan simply by paying the recent missed payments, rather than the entire balance.


The Court’s Decision:

The court ruled in favor of the homeowners. It held that a major loan modification counts as making or renewing a loan. Under California law, lenders cannot slip clauses into modification agreements that strip away a homeowner's statutory right to catch up on their payments.


[In some case parties can contract around statutory law. However, here the parties could not contract around Civil Code Section 2924c because of California Civil Code Section 3513, which establishes a fundamental rule: a law established for a public reason cannot be waived or contravened by a private agreement.]


The lender couldn't use the default on the modified payments as an excuse to ambush the homeowners with a massive, accumulated historical debt bill just to trigger a foreclosure.


What Do These Cases Mean Together?

Looking at both cases side by side, a clear picture emerges about how California law treats mortgage fixes:


  1. Paperwork Matters: As Secrest shows, informal deals, oral promises over the phone, or unsigned paperwork generally won't protect a homeowner. If a bank promises to change a loan, that agreement must strictly follow the rules—including being properly signed in writing.


  2. Consumer Protections Have Teeth: As Taniguchi shows, once a bank does legally modify a loan, it cannot use sneaky contractual "snap-back" clauses to bypass California's consumer protection laws. Homeowners keep their core statutory rights to cure defaults without being crushed by sudden, unfair financial demands.


Ultimately, both cases highlight the delicate balance between keeping people in their homes and holding both parties strictly accountable to the written terms of real estate contracts.

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page