Hannah Vu M.D. v. Yang: When a Missing Certificate of Occupancy Becomes a Landlord's Liability

In Hannah Vu, M.D. v. Yang, 2021 Cal. Super. LEXIS 147121, a Los Angeles Superior Court addressed the consequences of leasing commercial property that lacked the required certificate of occupancy. The court found that the landlord breached the lease, awarded damages to the tenant, and granted substantial attorney's fees.
The certificate-of-occupancy dispute
Hannah Vu rented commercial property for her medical practice. The City of El Monte later issued an administrative citation because the building lacked the required certificate of occupancy and could not lawfully be used. The landlord argued that he had obtained a different certificate and that the tenant's lease provisions placed responsibility on her.
Landlord responsibility for property-wide code issues
The court distinguished between alterations required because of a tenant's particular use and corrections required because of the property itself. The cited deficiencies predated the lease and prevented anyone from occupying the building. Under the lease, the landlord was responsible for those property-wide legal requirements.
A landlord cannot rely on an as-is clause to avoid responsibility for legal deficiencies that make the property unusable for any purpose.
Warranty and implied covenant claims
The lease stated that the office had passed final inspection. The court treated that language as a warranty that the building was suitable for occupancy. The landlord's failure to obtain the required certificate also breached the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing.
Damages and attorney's fees
The tenant recovered her $15,000 security deposit with interest, lost business income, moving expenses, and storage costs. The court also awarded $183,636.50 in attorney's fees. It explained that a prevailing party may recover fees even when it does not prevail on every claim, particularly where the claims involve overlapping work that cannot be meaningfully separated.
Important limits
The court did not find intentional fraud or fraudulent concealment because the tenant did not prove that the landlord knowingly made false statements with intent to deceive. The decision therefore illustrates the difference between negligence or breach of contract and the higher proof required for fraud and punitive damages.
This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Commercial lease, code-compliance, and damages issues are fact-specific and should be reviewed with a qualified California attorney.

Comments