top of page

Squatting for 13 Years Won’t Stop an Eviction: The Story of Estate of Mary Esther Bates

Writer: kestner  Law
kestner Law
Nov 1
3 min read

Imagine someone moves into a house without permission, stays there for over a decade, and refuses to leave. Every time the rightful owner tries to take the house back, the squatter files a brand-new lawsuit to stop the clock.

Can someone delay being kicked out simply by opening a new court case?

According to a California appeals court in Estate of Mary Esther Bates (August 19, 2026), the answer is no. When a lawsuit is filed just to stall an eviction, judges have the power to step in and put an end to the delay.

What Happened in the Case?

Mary Esther Bates owned a home on Athens Avenue in Oakland, California. After she passed away, Dustan Wright and others occupied the property.

According to the administrator handling Bates’s estate, Wright had lived in the house unlawfully for 13 years. Every time the estate tried to reclaim the property for Bates’s heirs, Wright filed lawsuits representing himself (in pro per), which dragged out the dispute across more than a decade.

In April 2025, the estate administrator filed a petition in probate court to formally eject Wright and take back possession of the home.

The "Freeze the Case" Tactic

When someone files a probate petition to recover property, California law gives the other person a special tool called abatement under California Probate Code § 854.

Under this rule, if you already have a separate civil lawsuit going on about the same property, the judge usually has to hit the "pause" button on the probate case until the other lawsuit finishes.

Just before the estate filed its petition, Wright had filed a separate civil lawsuit claiming ownership by adverse possession (often called "squatters' rights"). In response to the estate’s petition, Wright raised two defenses:

  1. The estate didn't properly deliver the legal papers to him.

  2. The probate judge had to freeze the case under Section 854 while his other lawsuit was pending.

Wright didn't even show up to the hearing.

The Probate Judge's Decision

The probate judge saw right through the stall tactic. Under Probate Code § 854, there is a major exception: the court will not pause the case if the other lawsuit was filed just to create a delay.

The probate judge found that:

  • The estate served the papers properly.

  • Wright’s separate lawsuit was filed purely for delay.

  • Wright had zero ownership rights to the home.

The judge ordered Wright and all other occupants to pack up and leave within 15 days and authorized the sheriff to remove them.

What the Court of Appeal Decided

Wright appealed, acting as his own lawyer. The California Court of Appeal (First District, Division Two) affirmed the order to evict him. The court pointed out several key legal lessons:

1. You Cannot Use Lawsuits as Delay Shields

The automatic pause rule under Probate Code § 854 exists to prevent two courts from deciding the same real issue at the same time. It is not a loophole to let someone drag out an unlawful stay on property. Because Wright offered no real evidence that his separate lawsuit was legitimate, the trial judge was right to reject the delay tactic.

2. If You Don't Bring It Up at the Hearing, You Lose It (Forfeiture)

On appeal, Wright tried to raise a long list of new arguments. The appellate court refused to consider them because of the rule of forfeiture: you cannot raise an argument for the first time on appeal. If you don’t bring it up to the trial judge in your written paperwork or at the hearing, the higher court will treat it as waived.

3. Clear Writing Matters in Court

The appeals court noted that Wright’s briefs were confusing, lacked proper legal citations, and failed to explain how the trial judge made a legal error. Even if you represent yourself without a lawyer, courts expect you to follow the rules of appellate procedure.

One Detail Left to Fix: Back Rent Damages

While the appeals court affirmed the eviction order, it noted an ambiguity in the money damages.

Under California Civil Code § 3334, damages for occupying a property without permission are generally capped at the fair rental value for the past 5 years (about $152,000 in this case). However, part of the probate court's written order accidentally calculated rent all the way back to 2012 (around $400,000). The appellate court pointed out this conflict so the trial court could clarify the exact dollar amount on remand.

The Big Takeaways

  • Courts Can Spot Delay Tactics: Filing a separate lawsuit will not save a squatter if the judge determines the suit is just an attempt to stall an eviction.

  • Preserve Your Arguments: You only get to argue on appeal what you properly presented to the trial judge.

  • Pro Per Litigants Must Follow the Rules: Representing yourself does not excuse you from providing clear legal arguments and citations to the record.

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page