Lewis Jorge Construction v. Pomona Unified: Why Future Construction Profits Were Too Uncertain

When a public agency breaks a construction contract, can the contractor recover profits from other projects it never won? In Lewis Jorge Construction Management, Inc. v. Pomona Unified School District, the California Supreme Court said no—not on the facts presented.
What happened
The Pomona Unified School District hired Lewis Jorge Construction to improve Vejar Elementary School for about $6 million. The project was delayed, and the District eventually terminated the contract and called on the contractor's surety to finish the work. The surety hired another contractor and later reduced Lewis Jorge's bonding capacity.
Because contractors often need bonds before they can bid on public projects, Lewis Jorge argued that the reduced bonding capacity prevented it from winning future work. A jury awarded approximately $3.15 million for those alleged lost profits.
The Supreme Court's decision
The Supreme Court reversed the lost-profits award. It explained that contract damages are meant to provide the benefit of the bargain—the value of what the parties agreed to—not every later business loss connected to the breach.
What are contract damages?
Contract damages are money awarded when one party fails to do what the contract required. The goal is to approximate the promised performance and put the injured party in roughly the same position it would have occupied if the contract had been fully performed. This is called receiving the benefit of the bargain.
There is also an important limit. California Civil Code section 3358 provides that damages for breach of contract cannot be greater than what the injured party would have received if both sides had fully performed. In simple terms, a lawsuit cannot turn one broken deal into a claim for every possible business opportunity that might have followed.
General damages versus special damages
The Court divided contract damages into two broad categories:
General damages are losses that flow directly, naturally, and necessarily from the breach. They are treated as part of the parties' expected bargain. They are based on the value of the promised performance itself, not on every consequence that performance might produce.
Special damages, also called consequential damages, are secondary losses caused by particular circumstances. Under the rule from Hadley v. Baxendale, these losses may be recovered only when the special circumstances were communicated to the breaching party, known to that party, or reasonably foreseeable when the contract was formed.
Why future, unawarded profits were not general damages
Lewis Jorge's claimed profits came from unidentified construction projects that it had not yet bid on and had not been awarded. The parties' bargain concerned one school-improvement project. It did not include potential profits from future projects.
The District's termination also did not directly or necessarily cause the loss of those future contracts. The immediate decision to reduce or suspend bonding came from the surety, which made its own business decision. That created a chain of events between the alleged breach and the claimed future profits.
For that reason, the future profits were not general damages. The profits Lewis Jorge expected to earn on the school project itself could be part of the value of that contract, but profits from projects that had not been bid on or awarded were outside the original bargain.
Why the future profits were not special damages here
The Court next considered whether the profits could qualify as special damages. The answer was still no because Lewis Jorge did not show that, when the contract was formed, the District actually foresaw—or reasonably should have foreseen—that a breach would probably cause the surety to reduce Lewis Jorge's bonding capacity and prevent it from obtaining future contracts.
The Court recognized that a contractor's bonding can sometimes be affected by a contract dispute. But that result is not automatic. It depends on the contractor's finances, the surety's standards, and the surety's independent decision. Without information showing that this chain of events was a reasonably probable result at the time of contracting, the claimed losses were not recoverable as special damages.
The practical lesson
Lost profits are not automatically unrecoverable simply because they involve the future. A contractor may recover future profits when it can show that they were reasonably certain to occur and that the law recognizes them as part of the bargain or as foreseeable consequential losses. But profits from projects that were never awarded are especially difficult to prove.
A contractor seeking this kind of recovery should identify the specific project, show that it was reasonably likely to win the work, prove the expected profit with reasonable certainty, and show that the other party knew or should have known about the risk when the contract was made.
Key takeaway
Lewis Jorge draws a clear line: contract damages compensate for the deal that was made—not for a chain of uncertain future opportunities that might have happened afterward. The benefit of the bargain is important, but it does not include every business loss that follows from a breach.

Comments