top of page

Owens v. Kings Supermarket: When Is a Business Responsible for an Accident on a Nearby Street?

Writer: kestner  Law
kestner Law
Oct 31
4 min read

If someone is injured by a car on a public street next to a supermarket, can the supermarket be held responsible simply because the person was shopping there? In Owens v. Kings Supermarket, the California Court of Appeal said no. The key issue was control: the supermarket did not own, possess, or control the public street where the accident occurred.

What happened

Robert Owens parked in a traffic lane in front of Kings Supermarket and got out of his car to buy a newspaper. Another vehicle rolled forward and crushed his legs against his car. Owens sued Kings, arguing that the supermarket had encouraged customers to use the street for parking and should therefore be responsible for the danger.

In his earlier complaints, Owens described the accident as occurring in the public street next to the supermarket. After the court rejected his initial legal theories, he amended his complaint to say that he had been injured on the supermarket's premises. The court refused to accept that change because he did not explain the inconsistency.

What is a demurrer?

A demurrer is a legal challenge to a complaint. It does not usually ask the court to decide which witnesses are believable or what really happened. Instead, it asks whether the facts alleged, if assumed to be true, are legally enough to support a claim.

On appeal, courts generally assume the complaint's factual allegations are true when reviewing a dismissal after a demurrer. But that rule has an important exception when a later complaint contradicts earlier pleadings in an apparent attempt to fix a legal problem.

The sham pleading exception

Courts do not allow a party to change important facts from one complaint to the next simply to avoid dismissal. Under the policy against sham pleading, the court may review the earlier complaints, require an explanation for the inconsistency, and disregard the new allegation if no reasonable explanation is provided.

In Owens, the original and first amended complaints repeatedly stated that the accident happened in the street. Only after the court rejected the argument that the supermarket's commercial use of the street created a duty did Owens allege that the accident occurred on the supermarket's premises. Because he offered no explanation, the Court of Appeal treated the accident as having occurred on the public street.

Duty is a legal question

In a negligence case, a duty of care is the legal obligation to act reasonably toward another person. Whether a defendant owes that duty is decided by the court as a question of law. If the court finds that no duty exists, that finding completely defeats the negligence claim.

An appellate court reviews this legal issue independently, without being bound by the trial court's reasoning. This is called de novo review, which simply means the appellate court makes its own legal decision.

Why the supermarket owed no duty for the street accident

Owens relied on two general premises-liability ideas. First, a property owner may sometimes be responsible for injuries off the property caused by a dangerous condition on land the owner possesses or controls. Second, a business may owe customers a duty to protect them from foreseeable harm caused by third parties while they are on the business's property.

Neither rule applied here. The accident occurred on a public street, not on property controlled by Kings. Premises liability is based on possession and control: a person who manages property can reasonably be expected to keep that property safe. But a supermarket does not have the legal power to control traffic, regulate public streets, or manage every parking area adjacent to its property.

The Court explained that extending a supermarket's duty to the surrounding public streets would create an unclear and potentially unlimited responsibility. Similar reasoning would require stores, theaters, and homeowners to provide lighting, security, or traffic control on city streets simply because their customers or guests used those streets.

The limited street-vendor exception

California courts have recognized a narrow situation in which a business may owe a duty to customers injured near a public street: the traveling street vendor. A vendor operating from a mobile truck conducts business directly in the street, invites customers to approach the truck, and can partly control where the truck stops and how customers reach it.

The Court refused to extend that exception to Kings Supermarket. Kings operated from a fixed location on private property. It was not conducting business from a vehicle in the street and did not have the same ability to supervise the immediate area around a mobile operation.

The court's decision

The Court of Appeal affirmed the dismissal of Owens's claim against Kings Supermarket. The supermarket did not owe him a duty for injuries caused by a third party on the adjacent public street, and the inconsistent allegation that the accident happened on the supermarket's premises could be disregarded.

The practical lesson

A business may be responsible for dangers on property it owns, possesses, or controls. That responsibility does not automatically extend to every public street, sidewalk, or parking area nearby. The location of the injury—and who had the legal power to manage that location—can determine whether a duty exists.

The case also shows why pleadings matter. A party cannot usually avoid a demurrer by changing a central fact without explaining why the earlier complaint said something different. Courts may rely on the earlier version and reject the later allegation as an attempt to repair a defective claim.

Key takeaway

Owens v. Kings Supermarket draws two clear lines: a demurrer tests whether the pleaded facts support a legal claim, and premises liability generally depends on control of the place where the injury occurred. A fixed-location business is usually not responsible for a third party's negligence on a nearby public street that the business does not own or control.

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page